NOLA Architecture with History
Sitting empty for nearly a quarter of a century, demolition of the Plaza Tower is long overdue.For preservationists seeing
neglected properties around New Orleans, their inclination almost always leans
heavily toward restoration or adaptive reuse. In most cases, abandoned
structures have the potential to thrive again, breathing new life into the community.
Sometimes, a building outlives its usefulness. Maybe it's a blight, a canker on
the face of the neighborhood, and a threat to the people who live, work, and
visit our city. One such building is Plaza Tower.
Construction of the Plaza Tower began in 1964
and was completed in 1969. It was designed by Leonard R. Spangenberg Jr., a
local architect who apprenticed under Frank Lloyd Wright. Though every project
faces complications, the fate of the tower seemed doomed from the beginning.
Sam Recile, the original real estate developer who wanted to build the tower,
ran into financial difficulties and was sued by the architectural firm Leonard
R. Spangenberg Jr. & Associates for over half a million dollars in unpaid
fees. Additionally, many criticized its construction, deeming the design an
"eyesore" that detracted from the surrounding historical architecture.
In its design, Spangenberg intended to blend
modernism, expressionism, futurism, and constructivism—a failed attempt,
according to critics. In an essay published by the Society of Architectural
Historians, authors Karen Kingsley and Lake Douglas describe the Plaza Tower as
"a jumble rather than a distillation" of the modern disciplines. Since the
Plaza was built, many residents disdainfully referred to it as the "air traffic
control tower" due to its austere, function-forward design and top-heavy hat,
which was originally intended to feature a helipad.
Vocal opponents and a mid-build lawsuit
resulting in a change of ownership weren't the Plaza Tower's only hurdles. In
1965, Hurricane Betsy struck while the tower was still under construction, and
the sustained winds of over 110 mph reputedly twisted the elevator shaft, an
issue that plagued the building's elevator operations throughout its existence.
On the bright side, when construction was completed, the 45-story, 531-foot
Plaza Tower was the tallest skyscraper in the New Orleans skyline, until the
Hancock Whitney Center (formerly One Shell Square) was completed three years
later in 1972.
After the Plaza Tower was completed in 1969,
it was intended primarily as office space with some residential units near the
top. Oddly enough, very little residential space was made available. As a
result, the remaining living areas were made into offices in the mid '80s.
The multi-million dollar tower's vitality was
short-lived, serving mainly as offices for state and city employees in its
final years. In 2001, several class action lawsuits were filed against the
building's owners and managers due to a lack of maintenance, exposing tenants
to asbestos and toxic mold. Only a year later, the building was vacated en
masse and has sat empty ever since, even though the structure underwent
environmental remediation from 2008 to 2010 under the ownership of Plainfield
Asset Management.
The owners of the Plaza Tower have been many
and varied, from Giannasca Development Group and Bahar Development of Ohio (who
were temporarily successful in their $6.5 million renovation) to Plainfield
Asset Management, a now-defunct hedge fund. Bryan Burns, a partner with JSW
Plaza Tower, purchased the building in 2011 for $650,000 and had grand plans to
develop it into a mixed use space with high end apartments and commercial
space, a move that would happen in conjunction with the blossoming South Market
District on Loyola Avenue. Unfortunately, those lofty plans never came to
fruition.
In 2014, the tower was purchased by Joe
Jaeger, a local real estate developer known for buying up neglected properties
for renovation or letting them sit and deteriorate before selling them to
another interested buyer. Since Jager purchased it in 2014, the Plaza Tower has
sat untouched for over a decade.
Over the years of neglect, the
tower fell further into disrepair, and, no matter how many barriers were
erected, it became a haven for danger-seekers, graffiti artists, and squatters.
It was only a matter of time before the crumbling structure became a danger. It
began in early summer 2021 when high winds dislodged a large piece of paneling,
which fell and injured a passing bicyclist. Several months later in January of
2022, a fire broke out after witnesses reported seeing smoke coming from the
tower. Then in April of 2023, a two-alarm "trash fire" broke out on the second
floor and, only hours after the fire, police discovered a homeless man who fell
from the tower and died.
Though netting was installed
around the Plaza's crown to catch falling debris, the move was only a temporary
stopgap. In 2023, Mayor LaToya Cantrell took aim at the city's blighted
properties, levying fines against the owners and threatening demolition. Plaza
Tower definitely topped her "dirty dozen" list, along with other neglected
buildings such as the Lindy Boggs Hospital on Norman C. Francis Parkway and
State Palace Theater on Canal Street.
In 2024, the Governmental
Affairs Committee of the New Orleans City Council approved $2.7 million in
funding toward stabilization, securing the building against future accidents.
More inspiring, just this past January, a judge ruled the city can go forward
with plans to eventually demolish the ill-fated tower, a move that came after
more legal tug of war between Jaeger and the city of New Orleans.
In anticipation of Super Bowl
LIX, the city invested in beautification projects, from costly, color-changing
LED lights on the Crescent City Connection and Disney-like projections on the
St. Louis Cathedral to expansive murals on the Entergy substation and Girod
Street overpass. As demolition of the Plaza Tower obviously couldn't happen
before the football festivities, the Super Bowl Host Committee wrapped the
first 10 floors with artwork. But an artistic band-aid won't long hide the
decay that has plagued the city's skyline for decades.
State Palace Theater
Distracted by opulent Garden District mansions and dressed fried shrimp po-boys, it was a few months before I realized New Orleans is a neglected city. When journeyed beyond self-delineated safety zones, I became spellbound by the crumbling buildings, graffiti tags, and trailing vines competing to conceal grand facades and curtain broken windows.
Born and raised in the San Francisco Bay Area, a metropolis with virtually no space left unsung, I found the abandoned structures in New Orleans both gloomy and alluring. Who built them? Why have they been forsaken? Will they ever be revived? This is a personal exploration of the abandoned and neglected public structures in New Orleans. This is Tumbledown NOLA.
Casey and Brandon were the first people I met when I moved here over 20 years ago. Being a decade older didn't stop the young couple from welcoming me into their city. With their guidance, I sucked and pinched my way through my first crawfish boil, spent late nights couch-bound, burning endless blunts in the Hi-Ho's backroom and early mornings gulping greasy spoon breakfasts at the Trolley Stop Cafe.
While never brave enough to accompany them, Casey and Brandon regaled me with stories of the raves they attended at State Palace, a crumbling theater on Canal Street. Though I'd enjoyed numerous beach raves in the Bay Area, I was more than a little afraid in what was still, to me, an unknown city. But their stories, and the building itself, fascinated me.
Opened nearly a century ago in 1926 with its distinctive Spanish Colonial Revival-inspired façade, The Palace was one of many Loew's Theaters popping up across the country. The Devil's Circus, starring Norma Shearer, was the first film listed on the marquee on opening night, and Marcus Loew himself appeared on stage with silent film stars Buster Keaton and Lew Cody, among others, heralding the Canal Street venue.
The Palace was designed by prominent, Scottish-born architect Thomas W. Lamb, known for the plush "movie palaces" he created for Fox, Keith Albee (RKO), and the Loews theater chains. The cinema he designed for the corner of Canal and Basin streets boasted a seating capacity for 3,335 people and a 3/13 Robert Morton pipe organ. Unfortunately, the organ fell into disuse after the early '30s with the advent of "talkies" and was later destroyed in a flood.
In the mid-70s, the theater was expanded to become a triplex, partitioned to feature two screens on the main floor while the balcony offered the third. Less than a decade later, the theater was sold to Wilson P. Abraham, a developer who planned to raze The Palace and build condominiums in its place—a plan that never came to fruition.
Rene Brunet Jr., beloved local owner of the Prytania Theater (among others) with the cinema in his blood, leased The Palace from Abraham in the late 1980s. In an attempt to bring the cinema back to its former glory, Brunet removed the partitions and opened up the balcony, uncovered the marble walls in the lobby, returned the single large screen to the main floor, and renamed the building the State Palace Theater. Along with showing classic films and television shows, the space became a live music venue, featuring performances by A-listers such as Stone Temple Pilots, Phish, and Green Day.
In the mid-90s (arguably the building's most fascinating era), the State Palace became the premier venue for raves, gaining national notoriety for its epic, wildly-themed EDM concerts featuring DJs from across the country. The late night performances were organized by local event producer James D. Estopinal Jr., aka Disco Donnie, star of the 2004 documentary film Rise: The Story of Rave Outlaw Disco Donnie. State Palace raves in their heyday included performances by drum and bass phenom Danny the Wildchild, hip hop DJ Q-Bert, Baltimore-based Charles Feelgood, and California's Bassbin Twins.
My friend Casey Sander, an avid fan of electronica and the local rave scene, recalled a State Palace concert featuring Rabbit in the Moon, a group whose style drew from house, trance, and breakbeat, and who were one of the first to mix theatrical stage performances into their acts. "I remember [State Palace] would get so packed that the walls would sweat. We wore those big-ass JNCO pants, and they would have six inches of nasty raver funk on the bottom." She also emphasized a sense of inclusivity. "No one cared at all about sexual orientation or race. Everyone was there participating together."
During the late-night raves, State Palace was split into three separate "rooms of sound." The main floor housed featured acts, the upstairs "jungle room" (an EDM genre dubbed jungle bass), and a side space they called the "chill room."
"Sometimes you could go out on the roof," recalled Sander. "I watched the sun rise from that roof multiple times." She also recalled the artistic event posters—collectible prints similar to the psychedelic, '60s era flyers for shows at the Fillmore in San Francisco.
In 1998, a 17-year-old girl attending a State Palace rave suffered convulsions from drug complications, went into a coma, and died. Estopinal and State Palace Theater became part of a nationwide federal investigation into raves and the drug culture that surrounded them. Undercover agents were sold ecstasy and LSD by attendees during several performances, but when they raided the theater, there was no evidence of drugs, just cases of water bottles, pacifiers, and glowsticks.
After Hurricane Katrina, the State Palace's basement flooded, leading to its closure. It briefly reopened in 2006, hosting its final "Zoolu" event the day before Mardi Gras, before shutting down permanently in 2008 due to fire code violations. Efforts to revive the theater began in 2014 when developer Gregor Fox purchased it, envisioning a restoration akin to successes at the nearby Saenger and Joy theaters. However, the estimated $50 million renovation price tag proved insurmountable and conflicting visions among investors stalled progress.
Fox sold the property to LC Hospitality Group, which planned to transform it into a hotel with ground-floor retail space. However, external setbacks like the Hard Rock Hotel collapse in 2019, rising interest rates, and COVID-19 delays halted these ambitions. Key proposals were also denied by the city's Historic District Landmarks Commission, further complicating the project.
As of July 2023, the State Palace is back on the market for $7.2 million. Whether this historic landmark will find new life remains uncertain. All we can do is wait and see.
